This is quite an artful novel. It has such elegance in the way the prose unfolds. It reminds me of Henry James, but without the meanness of Henry James. O'Sullivan, born in 1937, must have drawn on childhood memories of WWII and the immediate post-war era, because there is such a lively reality in this novel, and especially in the early scenes, set immediately after the war. It feels like we're running out of time to be graced with such fictional realism of these times. The author creates a sense of place that is very hard to pull off for writers born after the era they're writing about--something is lost once a given era recedes into the category of 'historical novel.'

There are so many small gestures and so many distinct and vivid observations in each scene. The things that O'Sullivan chooses to write about, and those he chooses to leave out, feel like unique and thoughtful choices, and nothing like the other 2018 novels I've read. A word that comes to mind to describe this novel is "genteel." An old-fashioned word for a quality that's difficult to find in contemporary fiction. The novel is filled with wonderful humane characters whom I cared about and who were remarkable individuals, people I would recognize if I ever met them.

My deep thanks to Marcus Hobson for sending me a copy of this wonderful novel! ( )

This is my final read of 2019's NZ Ockham Book Awards short list. It possibly suffered from a lack of concentration due to family events and I think it was as the story moved into a more contemporary New Zealand setting that I became more absorbed. ( )

All This by Chance was the last for me to read of the four titles shortlisted for the 2019 Ockham New Zealand Book Awards. Like the other titles (see links to my reviews gathered in one place here) it explores what it means to tell the truth:
“They stood out for their ability to explore personal memory and collective mediation of the truth in new and provocative ways that have a lasting impact on the reader,” says the Fiction category convenor of judges Sally Blundell. (Auckland Literary Festival website, viewed 10/4/19)
O'Sullivan, who among other distinctions was Poet Laureate in NZ from 2013-2015, is of Irish heritage, but the characters in All This by Chance have a heritage that they themselves are unsure about. The story is told in parts, from the unshared perspective and chronology of different generations, but all in third person narrative which effectively distances the characters from each other.
The story begins in postwar Britain, where a shy young pharmacist called Stephen escapes from Auckland, a place he sometimes hated, to a place he knew nothing of. There in 1947, in London, under the benign paternalism of David Golson, he begins both his career and a puzzled engagement with a post-Holocaust world. He meets and marries Eva, a woman without a past because she knows nothing at all about her family. As a baby she had been adopted out from Berlin, and then sent to safety with a Quaker family in England when anti-Semitism was on the rise. So it is a shock when the past that Eva has been shielded from emerges into their lives: an elderly aunt of whom she knew nothing has survived the Holocaust and been brought to London to be with the sole remnant of her family.
Ruth goes with them when the couple set sail for Auckland. She is, they were warned, badly damaged by her experience, but the gulf between them is not just because of the impenetrable barrier of unshared languages. A specialist tells them one day that they should be grateful that she remembers so little of the dreadful years in the camp. Yet Ruth seemed to know Miss McGovern when they recognised each other on the ship, and Miss McGovern becomes a regular if not really welcome visitor in Auckland. The genesis of their curious friendship remains unexplained for a long time, until in 1976 a Holocaust researcher panics Miss McGovern into telling Stephen their shared story. She and her sister Irma were imprisoned because they would not renounce their beliefs as Jehovah's Witnesses, and Ruth had suffered brutal and enduring punishment because she tried to help Irma in a moment of crisis. Miss McGovern now is terrified that the researcher will trigger cruel memories which have mercifully been lost. ( )